11 Thrift Stores In Cincinnati Curating The Best Eco-Cincy Style

If you wear your heart on your sleeve (and love animals), then this second hand shop in Cincinnati is for you.

Peppermint Pig Thrift & Gift is a thrift-store-meets-animal-rescue. The registered 501(c)(3) is volunteer operated and 100% of their proceeds support the Peppermint Pig Animal Rescue.

This no-kill animal rescue provides care and treatment to animals (mostly dogs) saved from high kill shelters, open intake shelters, and rural areas with high euthanasia rates.

With every purchase of the thrift store’s gently-used clothing, books, jewelry, household items, furniture, holiday items, and small appliances, you can help to pay for some of the vet bills and ensure their dogs and cats find a loving home.

Oh and feel free to bring your own fur babies while you peruse their wares, too.

Price: $-$$

And our top pick for the best vintage clothing thrift store in Cincinnati goes to, Pixel 19 Vintage.

With 10,000 square feet filled with diverse vintage stock, any shopper can find what they need, whether that’s vintage or retro clothes, hippie or biker vibes—with lots of $10 price tags.

This includes clothing (largely from the 1980s but as far back as the 1920s), accessories, shoes, art, lighting, decor, sculptures, furniture, and music and film memorabilia.

Everything is hand-picked and, while the shop is open to the general public, they also sell to costumers, stylists, vintage dealers, global collectors, and corporate companies.

In fact, you may have seen them featured on an episode of American Pickers.

Price: $-$$$

Want some creative inspo?

Then Scrap It Up is the reuse center and one of the best thrift stores in Cincinnati for the creatively inclined.

Their specialty is gently used art materials and other upcycled crafting items that could find a new life with artists, teachers, kids, parents, or students.

The women-run non-profit reuse center exists to encourage sustainable behavior by diverting art and craft items from the waste stream—all while providing low-cost supplies for creative projects.

The shop is open Wednesday-Saturday but donations require an appointment.

Price: $-$$

One-of-a-kind costumes, vintage garments and accessories. Talk of the Town will take you on a trip down memory lane.

Make sure you mark them on your calendar though as they’re only open on the weekend.

You can head to the top floor for costumes, or peruse the main floor for high-quality vintage items from any era.

With a lot of eye candy, expect to spend several hours sifting through racks of retro prints.

Price: $$-$$$

If you don’t know what you’re looking for but really love looking (and thrifting, of course), New2You is a second hand store not to be missed.

Their diverse range includes gently-used clothing, accessories, shoes, jewelry, housewares, accessories, furniture, electronics, records, games, books, VHS tapes, CDs, appliances, artwork, gifts, and more.

The volunteer-run nonprofit shop got its start in 2006 as a “biznistry”—a combination business and ministry outreach of Peoples Church Cincinnati.

For deep discounts, be on the lookout for their mic-dropping 50% off sales.

Price: $-$$

For a real shopping experience in yesteryear, Casablanca Vintage is one of the top thrift shops Cincinnati locals have access to.

For 35 years, they’ve been offering men’s and women’s clothing and accessories from the 1920s-1990s. You may even find ye-old items from the 1800s.

From costumes for theater and film, something to wear to a themed party, or day-to-day vintage apparel, everything is well-organized and the stock includes both high-end and affordable items.

They have options for buying, selling, and renting, and also love working with fashion designers and stylists.

The queer co-owned shop is also home to Awesome Time Shoe and Leather Repair, a shoe repair service.

Price: $-$$$

One of the premier second hand furniture stores, Legacies Upscale Resale curates high-end, designer jewelry, textiles, home decor, crystal, china, furniture, and art.

You can expect to find brand names like Haviland, Ethan Allen, and Stiffel—all at significant savings.

Primarily volunteer-run, all profits are donated to the Cancer Support Community of Greater Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky.

For more than 25 years, the resale shop has helped to provide free services to cancer patients and their families like workshops, classes, and support groups.

Donation and consignment options are available by appointment.

Price: $$-$$$

With several thrift stores in the Cincinnati, Ohio area, St Vincent de Paul is a popular pick among secondhand shoppers.

Purchases help to fund the faith-based organization’s neighborly support services. These include food and nutrition programs, health and wellness education, homelessness prevention, and provision of basic needs.

The thrift stores have a mix of modern and vintage clothing, shoes, accessories, books, housewares, furniture, and holiday items.

Turn up one day and you may score a 50% off sale.

Price: $-$$

With locations across the country—including 3 thrift stores in Cincinnati—Play it Again Sports is the place for sporty secondhand shopping.

The most affordable way to get into any activity, is to go for gently-used sports gear and fitness equipment, including disc golf supplies, free weights, bikes, skis, ice skates, and much more.

Which is exactly what they have to bring your sporting dreams to fruition.

Whether you’re trying out for the field hockey team, planning for the winter ski season, or looking for equipment for your home gym, they can help.

If you find that rugby isn’t your sport after all, you don’t even need an appointment to get cash outright or trade-in value for your equipment.

Price: $-$$$

Art majors rejoice!

Resale shops in Cincinnati have nothing on the creatively named, Indigo Hippo.

The 501(c)(3) nonprofit wants to make creativity accessible, which is why they offer pay-what-you-can pricing for their creative materials. Each item has a tag with a range of prices—you choose how much you pay.

These include essentials for drawing + illustration, knitting + yarn, jewelry + beads, print + printmaking, fabric + sewing, stamps + stickers, crafts + random fun, paper + office supplies, books + picture frames, floral + containers, tile + wood, tools + hardware, and kits.

They regularly collaborate with local organizations and provide free supplies for those in need.

They’re open Thursday-Saturday and anyone can make an appointment to donate or volunteer.

Price: $-$$

With an unmatched selection of furniture, decorative decor, lighting, and art, Astute Furnishings can help you deck out your living space.

The store offers eclectic to eccentric, including mid-century, vintage, art deco, antique, and modern pieces.

They’ve been in the business since 1993, making them Cincinnati’s oldest furniture consignment business. They offer competitive pricing and convenient consignment opportunities.

If you can’t make it into the showroom personally, you can also shop online.

Price: $$-$$$